Digital marketing consultant or agency: which do you need?
A digital marketing consultant is the right choice when you need advice, a plan or a second opinion and you have people who can do the work. A digital marketing agency is the right choice when you want the work done and one team accountable for the result. Most NZ business owners who search for a consultant actually want the second thing.
This guide explains what a consultant does, how they differ from an agency, what each costs in rough terms, and how to tell which one you need. It is written for an owner deciding who to call, not for a marketer.
What does a digital marketing consultant do?
A consultant advises. An agency executes. A consultant looks at your marketing, tells you what is wrong and what to do about it, and usually hands the plan back to you or your team to carry out.
Typical consultant work includes:
- Reviewing an ad account, website or funnel and writing up what to fix
- Building a marketing plan, budget split and channel mix
- Coaching an in-house marketer or training your staff
- Helping you brief and manage an agency or freelancer
Some consultants also do hands-on work, and some agencies sell advice only. The label matters less than the answer to one question: who builds the ads, pages and tracking, and who is on the hook if they do not work?
How is a consultant different from an agency?
The difference is who does the work and who carries the risk. A consultant is usually one person selling their judgement. An agency is a team selling finished work.
| Consultant | Agency | |
|---|---|---|
| Main output | Advice, plans, audits | Live campaigns, pages, reports |
| Who does the work | You or your team | The agency team |
| Typical billing | Hourly, day rate or short project | Monthly retainer, sometimes plus set-up |
| Accountable for results | Rarely, they advise | Usually, they run the account |
| Best when | You can execute but need direction | You cannot or do not want to execute |
The trap is hiring a consultant and expecting results. A strong plan that nobody builds produces nothing. If you have no one to build it, you are paying twice: once for the plan and again for whoever carries it out. Our guide on what a digital marketing agency actually does shows the work a consultant's plan still has to be turned into.
What does each cost in NZ?
A consultant costs less per month but buys you less finished work. These are rough ranges from what we see in the NZ market. They are not a published survey and not a quote.
| Option | Typical NZ cost (our experience) | What you still pay for |
|---|---|---|
| Consultant, hourly | $100 to $300 an hour | Everything the plan needs built |
| Consultant, ongoing advice | $1,000 to $4,000 a month | A person or team to do the work |
| Agency retainer | $1,500 to $10,000+ a month | Ad spend, which is separate |
Ad spend sits on top of all of them. If you are weighing the agency side, our guide to what a digital marketing agency costs in NZ breaks down the bands and how fees are structured. Use the ad spend calculator to work out what budget a target number of leads needs before you commit to either.
When is a consultant the right call?
Hire a consultant when you have the hands but not the direction. That usually means one of these:
- You have an in-house marketer or a capable team, and they need a plan and someone to challenge it
- You are about to hire an agency and want help writing the brief and judging the proposals
- You want a one-off audit of ads, a website or tracking before you spend more
- Your marketing works but has stalled, and you want a fresh set of eyes
A consultant is a poor fit if nobody on your side has the time or skill to carry out what they recommend. In that case the report sits in a drawer and you are no further ahead.
When is an agency the right call?
Choose an agency when you want leads and you want one team to own getting them. Ads, landing pages, tracking and how fast you answer enquiries all decide whether ad spend turns into customers. An agency covers those together, so you are not the project manager.
An agency is not worth it if your budget is so small that the fee swallows the return, or if you only need one task done. For a single task, a freelancer is often better, and our comparison of agency, freelancer and in-house lays out when. If you already run ads and want an independent opinion before you decide, the free ads audit gives you one without a contract.
How do you decide which you need?
Ask who will do the work, then check the people behind the advice. Work through these in order.
- Who will build it? If the answer is nobody, you need an agency, or a consultant plus a builder.
- Do you need advice or results? Advice points to a consultant. Results point to an agency.
- Can you judge the work? If not, an advisor who tells you what good looks like is valuable, but you still need someone to deliver it.
- What is the exit? Prefer short terms. Ask what happens to your ad account, ads and tracking if you stop. You should own all three.
Whoever you pick, ask for work you can inspect: a sample audit, the account structure, or a clear description of what happens in month one. Our guide on how to choose a digital marketing agency has the questions to ask before you sign. Be wary of anyone who promises a specific return before they have seen your numbers, because nobody honest can.
Can you use a consultant and an agency together?
Yes, and it works well when each has a clear job. A consultant can write the brief, set the budget and review the agency's work each quarter. The agency builds and runs the campaigns. The consultant works for you, so their view is independent of the agency's fee.
The cost is a second bill and a second voice in the room. For a business spending a few thousand dollars a month on ads, that is usually more layers than you need. It starts to pay off when the spend is large, when you have several channels, or when you have been burned before and want someone watching the agency.
If you want that independent check without hiring anyone, ask any agency you are considering to explain its plan in plain language and to show you the account it would build. A good one will.
What should make you walk away?
Be wary of anyone who sells certainty. Marketing results depend on your offer, your price, your follow-up speed and your market, and nobody can promise them before seeing your numbers.
- A guaranteed return or a guaranteed number of leads
- A plan with no mention of tracking, so you could not tell whether it worked
- A long lock-in contract, or ad accounts and tracking held in their name rather than yours
- A consultant who cannot say who will carry out the plan
- Vague reports full of impressions and clicks but no leads or revenue
A good advisor tells you when something is not worth doing. If every recommendation involves spending more, ask what you would stop doing and why.