See if we're a fit

Guides · Google Ads

Should you hire a Google Ads agency, a consultant, or run it yourself?

By Dylan Murray · Updated 30 October 2026 · 6 min read

Run it yourself if your spend is small and you have a few hours a week. Hire a consultant if you want one experienced person and are happy to depend on them. Hire an agency if the account is big enough, or the tracking broken enough, that you need more than one skill and a backup. The right choice depends on your spend, your time and how well you can already tell a lead from a click.

This guide compares the three on the things that decide results: who does the work, who owns the account, what happens when the person leaves, and what each option costs you when it goes wrong.

What an agency, a consultant and DIY each mean

A Google Ads agency is a team. One person talks to you, another builds campaigns, another handles tracking and reporting. A Google Ads consultant is one person doing all of that, or a freelancer who may bring in a developer for tracking. DIY means you run the account yourself in Google's own interface.

The labels blur. Some agencies are two people and a laptop. Some consultants have a bench of subcontractors. Ignore the label and ask three questions: who will actually touch my account, what happens when they are sick or leave, and whose login is the account under. Our Google Ads management is run on that last point: the account stays in your name, always.

When running it yourself is the right call

DIY makes sense when your monthly spend is small, your category is not crowded, and you can give the account two or three hours every week. In our experience, below that level most of a management fee buys work a careful owner can do alone. If you are at that stage, read whether $10 a day is enough for Google Ads first, because a small budget changes what you should expect.

DIY works if you do four things:

  • Turn off auto-apply recommendations. They push you toward more spend and broader targeting, which suits Google's revenue first.
  • Track real enquiries. Count calls and form fills, not page views.
  • Read the search terms report weekly. Add the searches that waste money as negative keywords.
  • Stay on Search at first. Skip Performance Max until you have enough conversions for it to learn from.

DIY is not worth it if you cannot spare the weekly hours. An account checked once a month leaks money between checks, and nobody notices.

When a consultant fits

A consultant fits when you want one experienced person who knows your account in detail and answers to you directly. You get focus and usually a faster reply. You also get a single point of failure. If that person gets sick, gets busy or stops taking clients, your account sits idle or gets handed to a stranger.

Check these before you sign with a consultant:

  • Who does the tracking. Many consultants run campaigns well and tracking badly, or the other way round. Ask to see a conversion setup they built.
  • What the backup is. Ask what happens to your account if they are unavailable for two weeks.
  • How many accounts they carry. One person can run only so many accounts well. Ask how many they run and how often they check yours.

A good consultant beats a poor agency. The reverse also holds. Size tells you nothing about quality, so judge the work, not the headcount.

When an agency fits

An agency fits when the account needs more than one skill: campaign strategy, tracking, landing pages and reporting all at once. It also fits when you cannot afford the account going dark because one person left. You pay more for that cover, and you should get something for it: a named person on your account, and a second person who can step in.

The risk with an agency is that your account becomes one of many, handled by whoever is junior and free that week. Ask who logs in to your account, not who attends the sales call. The broader question of choosing between these models for all your marketing is covered in agency, freelancer or in-house.

An agency also makes sense when the problem sits after the click. Most Google Ads money is lost on the landing page or in slow follow-up, and an agency that runs the page and the reply as well as the ads can fix what a campaign-only consultant cannot.

How each option fails

Each option has a typical failure, and knowing it helps you spot it early.

  • DIY fails quietly. Nobody is accountable, so waste builds between checks. The usual sign is a rising cost per enquiry that you only notice at the end of the quarter.
  • A consultant fails suddenly. The account runs well until the person gets busy or leaves. The usual sign is slower replies and fewer changes in the account history.
  • An agency fails slowly. The work drifts to a junior and the reports get longer while the results stay flat. The usual sign is a monthly report full of clicks and impressions and no mention of customers.

You can catch all three the same way. Open the account's change history once a month and read what was changed, by whom and why. A healthy account shows steady, specific changes: new negative keywords, new ad copy, budget moves. An idle one shows nothing for weeks.

The checks that matter more than the label

Whichever you choose, five questions separate a good provider from a poor one. They work on agencies and consultants alike.

  1. Who owns the account? You should have administrator access under your own email from day one. If the account sits inside their manager account and you cannot get in, you rent a seat.
  2. Who owns the billing? Google should bill your card, not theirs. Cancelling a contract does not pause the ads, so know how to pause them yourself.
  3. What counts as a conversion? If page views or button clicks count, the report will look good and mean nothing. Ask for enquiries and, where your CRM allows, closed sales.
  4. What is the minimum term? A long lock-in protects them while the account is still being set up. Month to month lets you leave if it is not working.
  5. How do they report? You want leads, cost per lead and revenue, not impressions and clicks.

We go deeper on fees, ownership and lock-ins in how much to pay someone to manage your Google Ads.

What the choice is really worth

The fee is not the number that decides this. What the account returns is. $13,149 into Google Ads returned $35,222 of closed deals, a 2.7x return, in closed work. Video Taxi, an Auckland video production business, ran that account from 3 June 2025 to 7 May 2026: three closed deals carried a Google Ads source in their CRM, from 50 form enquiries. The account had run for years before that with no way to tell which clicks became paying work. The change was tracking and a tested landing page, not a bigger budget.

That is the point of the whole decision. Pick the option that can fix tracking and follow-up, not the one with the lowest fee or the biggest logo. Use the ad spend calculator to work out what your own numbers would need to look like for Google Ads to pay.

How to decide

Work through it in this order:

  • Can you give the account two or three hours a week? If yes and your spend is small, start DIY and learn what a good account looks like.
  • Is the problem tracking or follow-up? If you cannot tell which clicks become customers, hire someone who fixes that first. An agency that runs the page and the reply suits this best.
  • Do you want one person who knows your business? A consultant suits that, if you accept the single point of failure.
  • Is the account already running and not performing? Get a second opinion before you change provider. The fault is often in tracking or the landing page, not the person running the campaigns.

If you already pay someone and cannot tell whether it is working, our free ads audit gives you a second opinion on the account without you changing anything.

Common questions.

Is a Google Ads agency better than a consultant?

Neither is better by default. An agency gives you several skills and cover if someone leaves. A consultant gives you one experienced person and faster replies, but a single point of failure. Judge the work and the ownership terms, not the label.

Can I run Google Ads myself?

Yes, and it makes sense on a small budget if you can spare a few hours a week. Turn off auto-apply recommendations, track real enquiries and check the search terms report every week.

How do I know if a Google Ads agency is any good?

Ask who owns the account, who holds the billing, what counts as a conversion and what the minimum term is. A good provider gives you administrator access under your own email and reports on leads and sales, not clicks.

Should I switch Google Ads provider if results are poor?

Check tracking and the landing page first. Poor results often come from counting the wrong conversions or sending clicks to a weak page, and a new provider inherits the same fault unless someone fixes it.

Do I need a Google Ads agency for a small budget?

Usually not at the start. On a small budget most of a management fee buys work an owner can do. Bring in help once the account is large enough that a mistake costs real money, or tracking sits outside your skills.

See if we're a fit.

A few questions, then Dylan calls you within one working day.

Rather talk now? Call +64 21 298 2679.

What are you doing for marketing now?

We use your details to call you back, and never sell them. Privacy policy